Sunday, October 20, 2019
Word Choice Comprise vs. Compose
Word Choice Comprise vs. Compose Word Choice: Comprise vs. Compose At this rate, it wonââ¬â¢t be long before even pedantsà give up on the difference between ââ¬Å"compriseâ⬠and ââ¬Å"compose.â⬠After all, ââ¬Å"compriseâ⬠is frequently misused, particularly by people writing ââ¬Å"comprised ofâ⬠when they mean ââ¬Å"composed of.â⬠But itââ¬â¢s our job as Guardians of Language (it sounds snazzier than ââ¬Å"proofreadersâ⬠) to defend against grammatical abuses. So, in this post, we explainà how ââ¬Å"compriseâ⬠and ââ¬Å"composeâ⬠should be used. Comprise (To Contain or Include) The verb ââ¬Å"compriseâ⬠means ââ¬Å"containâ⬠or ââ¬Å"consist of,â⬠so it is used when describing a whole that includes multiple parts or components: The United States comprises fifty states. Here, ââ¬Å"comprisesâ⬠shows that the United States (as a whole) includes fifty individual states. Typically, when using ââ¬Å"comprise,â⬠the whole should come before the parts in the sentence. Compose (To Make Up or Constitute) While also a verb, ââ¬Å"composeâ⬠means ââ¬Å"make upâ⬠or ââ¬Å"constitute.â⬠As such, we could invert the example above to say: Together, fifty states compose the United States as a republic. In this sentence, the focus is on how the fifty individual states combine to form the United States as a country. Those stars arent just there to look pretty. [Photo: Jnn13]We also see why ââ¬Å"composed ofâ⬠is acceptable while ââ¬Å"comprised ofâ⬠isnââ¬â¢t, since ââ¬Å"composeâ⬠focuses on the parts that constitute the whole. We can therefore rewrite the example sentence again as: The United States is composed of fifty states. More generally, ââ¬Å"composeâ⬠can also mean ââ¬Å"create an artistic workâ⬠(particularly music or a painting), or even ââ¬Å"calm oneselfâ⬠(where its a variation of ââ¬Å"composure,â⬠meaning tranquility). Comprise or Compose? The problem with ââ¬Å"comprised ofâ⬠is that ââ¬Å"compriseâ⬠is the opposite of ââ¬Å"compose,â⬠not a synonym. In short, they canââ¬â¢t be used interchangeably. One good way to remember this is the following: The whole comprises the parts; the parts compose the whole. Here we see how both terms refer to how something is constituted, but from opposite directions; while ââ¬Å"compriseâ⬠describes the components as belonging to a whole, ââ¬Å"composeâ⬠describes the whole as constituted by its parts.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.